San Francisco Policy & Courts
SF Leaders Revive BUILD Act Tax Cut as Public Defender Appeals Fine
Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood reintroduced legislation trimming transfer taxes on $10 million-plus sales to spur housing construction while Public Defender Manu Raju challenged a $26,000 fine.

Your listening Queue & catch up
Add a story or build a catch-up queue to start listening.
Fiscal housing legislation and courtroom caseload disputes took center stage in San Francisco on Thursday as Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood revived the BUILD Act to reduce commercial and multifamily real estate transfer taxes, while attorneys for elected Public Defender Manu Raju argued before a state appellate panel to overturn a $26,000 judicial contempt fine.
According to The San Francisco Standard, Lurie and Mahmood reintroduced the BUILD Act—originally proposed in February and paused after the June election amid budget deficit concerns—following voters' passage of Proposition J this month. Sponsored by Lurie and Mahmood, Proposition J closed a loophole that had allowed lenders to avoid transfer taxes on foreclosed properties, generating revenue that Mahmood said will fully offset the proposed rate reductions and keep the city's roughly $360 million fiscal-year transfer tax projection revenue-neutral. Under a 2024 ballot measure authorizing the Board of Supervisors to lower transfer tax rates by ordinance, the bill—which Mahmood expects to pass next month—partially unwinds a 2020 voter measure that had doubled rates on $10 million-plus sales. The legislation lowers the tax rate on transfers between $10 million and $25 million from 5.5% to 3.5% and on sales of $25 million or more from 6% to 4% (still above the pre-2020 levels of 2.75% and 3%), while completely exempting the first transfer of newly constructed or converted multifamily buildings with three or more units and early infrastructure transfers under development agreements. Housing Action Coalition Executive Director Corey Smith praised the exemption as one of the fastest ways to move approved apartment projects into construction, whereas Tenants Together Legislative and Communications Director Shanti Singh criticized the tax reduction at a time when tenants face rent increases of up to 25%.
In state appellate court on Thursday, KALW reported that attorneys for San Francisco Public Defender Manu Raju presented oral arguments challenging a $26,000 contempt fine ordered in March by Superior Court Judge Harry Dorfman. Judge Dorfman imposed the $26,000 sanction after citing 26 criminal cases that the Public Defender's Office declined to accept, while Raju's office argued its attorneys already carried caseloads too high to ethically represent additional defendants. Public Defender spokesperson Vallerie Ibarra said the trial judge had attempted to override the office's leadership and data regarding constitutional representation standards. Following Thursday's hearing, the appellate court has 90 days to issue a ruling.
Sources
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought on this story.
Nominate a neighbor or local businessRequest a correctionContact the newsroom